Scott Stoll logo world traveler. A bicycle wheel and the globe symbolizes Scott's journey around the world on a bicycle.
The Giving Tree redux. A new ending with new pictures. The man sits on the stump with the caption, "And the tree was happy." But was it really?
The Giving Tree sequel (redux). Four new pages with new pictures added to "The Giving Tree" to make it more inspiring and eco-friendly. Illustrated and type set in the style of the original. Pictured here are pages 1-2 of 4.

The Giving Tree Sequel

How It Should Have Ended (HISHE)

The Giving Tree sequel (redux). The final pages revised. The old man reaches into his pocket and discover long lost seeds. A seed grows into a new tree.
What if instead of the tree being reduced to a stump the cycle of life continues with a lesson conveyed to the next generation, both a grandson and an apple sapling?
The Giving Tree by Shel Silverstein
The Giving Tree by Shel Silverstein

Have you ever read the classic children’s story “The Giving Tree” by Shel Silverstein? I’ve always been disturbed that the tree sacrifices itself to a greedy old man — so I rewrote the ending and drew new pictures. Call it: The Giving Tree Sequel or The Giving Tree Redux. The last 4 pages pictured here are my new ending. I also matched the layout, font and typesetting exactly to the original book.

Last seen the old man is sitting on the stump of the tree looking forlorn. The tree is happy to see his old friend and offers him a place to sit; that is all the tree has left to give. But, presumably, the man is unhappier than ever after having taken the tree’s friendship for granted and realizing he has killed the tree with his greed. Giving credit to the original author, Shel Silverstein, perhaps the young readers are meant to learn to stop being so greedy and destructive, yet I wonder why the tree is still happy? And the man seems little changed by his actions, so there is not much character growth there.

Alternate ending to The Giving Tree

What if instead of the tree being reduced to a stump, the cycle of life continues with a lesson conveyed to the next generation, both a grandson and an apple sapling? Please see my pictures and words above.

Falling Uphill children's edition read it free online

Thoughts?

Let me know how you think the Giving Tree should have ended in the comments below. Some people have made good arguments.

Also, I’m a children’s author. You can read one of my stories for free here. It is the children’s edition of about my bicycle ride around the world. Perhaps you’ll think it needs a new ending, too. Haha.

If you enjoyed this story… 

I’d love to hear your thoughts in the comments below.

If you are feeling generous, donations help keep me caffeinated and inspired. Even $1 helps. Or send an anonymous gift book from my Amazon Wishlist. Thanks. 

Subscribe to our monthly newsletter.  

You’ll never miss an update. And you’ll get some fun stuff, like discounts and free links to download my popular worksheets.  

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

12 Comments

  1. You completely missed the point of the book. The tree was happy at the end because the tree loved the man with the pure, selfless love that parents are called to give to their children. It didn’t condition its love on the man’s gratitude or reciprocation, just as parents shouldn’t condition the love for their children. Your ending obviates the whole point of the story. If you deny the role of sacrifice – true sacrifice – in life, you will blind yourself to its true beauty.

    1. Hi Patrick, I like this interpretation a lot, especially from the POV of a parent. I’ll have to think about this more. I just wish this allegory wasn’t in the form of humans vs nature. Thx for your comment.

  2. Modified end is good. I myself thought of two diffrent ends to this story. 1. When boy seat on the stump and thinking that the tree gave him everything it had and in return he did nothing. By this thought his his eyes became wet and tears started flowing down, down to the root of stump. And lo and behold…the new shoot came out of the old stump and the tree was happy.

  3. I almost started crying. I haven’t read this book in forever and I rember the ending petty well, but this was even better! :,)

  4. I’ve returned to this book for almost 50 years .. from a young child to an older woman. I still treasure it and your ending encapsulates the “redemption” theme In many ways. However, the Giving Tree must somehow learn not to give so much of herself that she has nothing left for her. No martyrdom. She needs Boundaries please.

    1. Thanks for your comment. You added a whole new level of meaning for me. Of course, the tree has a lesson to be learned, too. Maybe the book needs yet another page? Or is it best left to the reader’s imagination.

More stories like this

I've never wanted to measure my life by money, which lately has been an overly idealistic philosophy; nonetheless, I believe in measuring my life by new experiences and new opportunities.
8 steps to designing the perfect logo with examples and descriptions. Tips from concept to execution. Featuring some of Scott's best graphic design.
Footprint in the sand

Subscribe to my newsletter ​

I enjoy sending short stories about my adventures. I also send updates with free worksheets, new books and inspirational ideas to help you live a more joyful and meaningful life.